‘This is very much not our cat’: Pawrents rescue missing cat Chebby, but the reunion takes a twist when they discover an adorable impawster with swapped socks

In this tail of furocious confusion, a pawrent thought they had finally reunited with their missing feline, Chebby —Red Lobster Cheddar Bay Biscuit, if you want to use his full government name. After days of searching, a tip came in about a cat that looked purrfectly similair to Chebby. The tell-tail identifier was Chebby's white paws, complete with a hole in his left sock. Could this be the long-lost kitty?

Plot twist - the cat wasn't Chebby. 

When the mystery meowster was finally coaxed out from under the bed (where he was clearly doing some serious hide-and-seek), the pawrent noticed something: the hole in his paw was on the right sock, not the left! The markings were close enough to make any cat lover paws and do a double take, but this was a completely different furball. With dim lighting, low-quality photos, and a sneaky cat under the bed, the catastrophic mix-up made sense at first.

 Now, the pawrent has claws for concern: where is the real Chebby, and what to do with this sweet impawster? While we await Chebby's return, maybe this sock-swapping stray was just trying to fill the paw-shaped hole — and might be the purrfect mismatched pair after all.

Author image for Sarah Brown Sarah Brown
Advertisement

For a weekly dose of animal-themed community challenges - Subscribe to our Newsletter!

Can't get enough of ICanHasCheezburger? Find us on Instagram!

Tags

missing adorable socks lost and found reunion feline pawrents Cats stray rescue
Scroll Down For The Next Article

Also From I Can Has Cheezburger?

27 Supremely Silly Cat Children Who Can’t Handle the Chaos of Monday

27 Supremely Silly Cat Children Who Can’t Handle the Chaos of Monday

Trending Now

'The vets at the shelter had deemed her unadoptable': Amazing woman rescues a kitten clinging to life and a dog scheduled to be euthanized, giving them a second chance, and the two become best friends

'The vets at the shelter had deemed her unadoptable': Amazing woman rescues a kitten clinging to life and a dog scheduled to be euthanized, giving them a second chance, and the two become best friends

01
20+ Feline Funnies for People Who Want to Laugh, Nap, and Pet Something Soft

20+ Feline Funnies for People Who Want to Laugh, Nap, and Pet Something Soft

02
A Cute Concoction of Wholesome Feline Posts That Are Like Comical Catnip for Cat Lovers

A Cute Concoction of Wholesome Feline Posts That Are Like Comical Catnip for Cat Lovers

03
Good Morning Meows of Cat Memes for Pet Owners Running on Coffee and Cuddles (October 29, 2025)

Good Morning Meows of Cat Memes for Pet Owners Running on Coffee and Cuddles (October 29, 2025)

04
23 Pictures of Cats Serving Comfort, Cuteness, and Cozy Loaf Energy

23 Pictures of Cats Serving Comfort, Cuteness, and Cozy Loaf Energy

05
New 5 month old shelter cat adopted to good home, but turns into chaotic kitty with zoomies at 4 am every night, keeping pet owners awake all night: 'We tried playing with him for like an hour and a half straight, he doesn’t stop'

New 5 month old shelter cat adopted to good home, but turns into chaotic kitty with zoomies at 4 am every night, keeping pet owners awake all night: 'We tried playing with him for like an hour and a half straight, he doesn’t stop'

06
Advertisement